What's My Line?
Note, all episodes of the Daly version are rated B+ to A unless otherwise noted
John Charles Daly (86 episodes)
- (10-1-50) Mystery Guest: Kathleen Winsor (Long lost episode discovered in 2016. Missing the last few minutes) [KINwOC/CC-2/A]
- (12-31-50) Mystery Guest: Guy Lombardo [GSN/CC-2/B+]
- (4-29-51) Mystery Guest: Hedda Hopper (Long lost episode discovered in 2016. Ripped from YouTube with on-screen watermark at various points. FANTASTIC questioning with a mattress manufacturer who is a great sport that absolutely would've made blooper specials if this episode had existed before its rediscovery!!) [KINw/OC/CC-2/A]
- (10-5-52) Mystery Guest: Bette Davis [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (3-8-53) Mystery Guest: Jackie Gleason [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (5-17-53) Mystery Guest: Mickey Mantle [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-4-53) Mystery Guest: Gene Autry in one game, World Series umpire Ed Hurley in another!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (11-8-53) Mystery Guest: Lauren Bacall [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (12-13-53) Mystery Guest: Dave Garroway [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-14-54) Mystery Guest: Julius LaRosa [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-21-54) Mystery Guest: Lucille Ball [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (9-12-54) Mystery Guest: Alfred Hitchcock, as well as Miss America Lee Meriwether in another game!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (6-19-55) Mystery Guest: Arnold Stang [GSN/CC-1/A+, also available with OC from BUZZR on CC-2 in the same quality]
- (7-24-55) Mystery Guest: Robert Q. Lewis [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-2-55) Mystery Guest: Desi Arnaz and Lucille Ball [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (10-9-55) Mystery Guest: Hal March [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-4-55) Mystery Guest: Vivian Blaine [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-25-55) Mystery Guest: Peter Lind Hayes and Mary Healy (Sylvette de Aldrey, a panelist on the Puerto Rican version of the show, is a contestant, and afterwards she joins the panel to play the Mystery Guest game as well as the last civilian contestant game!! Johnny Marks, writer of the song "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, is a contestant) [BUZZRw/OC/CC-2/A+]
- (2-5-56) Mystery Guests: Randolph Churchill in one game, Kim Novak in another [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (7-22-56) Mystery Guest: Jerry Lewis (Paul Winchell is on the panel, and the man who designed his dummy, Jerry Mahoney, signs in as Mr. X to surprise Paul!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-28-56) Mystery Guest: Charlton Heston [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (11-11-56) Mystery Guest: Walt Disney [GSN/CC-1/A+, also available in the same quality from BUZZRw/OC]
- (5-26-57) Mystery Guest: Sammy Davis, Jr. [BUZZRw/OC/CC-2/A+]
- (6-23-57) Mystery Guest: Gene Kelly [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (11-3-57) Mystery Guest: Jack Lemmon [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (6-15-58) Mystery Guest: Bob Crosby [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (3-8-59) Mystery Guest: Fred MacMurray [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (6-21-59) Mystery Guest: Jack Benny (As always Jack Benny steals the show with a great round) [GSN/CC-2]
- (9-20-59) Mystery Guest: Claudette Colbert (The is the *legendary* episode with Groucho Marx on the panel as he absolutely destroys the show by shutting down and making a mockery of its entire structure and leaving everyone in stitches the entire time. One of the greatest and funniest bits of 50s TV you will ever see in your entire life. It feels like they purposely picked these specific contestants because they knew they'd be tremendous getting grilled by Groucho, including a man who looks so strikingly like Nikita Khrushchev (even JOHN cracks jokes about it) that Groucho's "are you a corrupt politician?" question knocks the entire house down, and legendary women's professional wrestler Judy Grable, whose round is a HILARIOUS disaster where Groucho's remarks even make Dorothy crack, and then John finally gets fed up after having his worst laughing fit of his life!!) [GSN/CC-2]
- (2-7-60) Mystery Guest: Julie Andrews (It's the show's 10th anniversary as well as the 500th episode!!) [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (7-17-60) Mystery Guest: Jerry Lewis [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (8-21-60) Mystery Guest: Buddy Hackett [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-16-60) Mystery Guest: Danny Kaye (The show is only 25 minutes tonight due to another special airing later in the night, so the show moves at a slightly quicker rate!!) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-23-60) Mystery Guest: Janet Leigh (New York Yankees manager Ralph Houk is a Mystery Guest in the first game as well!!) [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (12-11-60) Mystery Guest: Stephen Boyd [GSN/CC-1]
- (1-1-61) Mystery Guest: Lucille Ball [GSN/CC-1]
- (1-15-61) Mystery Guest: Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1-22-61) Mystery Guest: Mahalia Jackson [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1-29-61) Mystery Guest: Fashion designer Oleg Cassini in one game, Julie Newmar in another [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (7-2-61) Mystery Guest: Yogi Berra [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-3-61) Mystery Guest: Janet Leigh [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-4-62) Mystery Guest: Mark Goodson and Bill Todman in one game, and Bob Newhart in another (Mark and Bill are here to congratulate the panel on the 12th anniversary of the show) [GSN/CC-2]
- (10-7-62) Mystery Guest: Melina Mercouri (A man, hilariously called a "bad-mannered visitor" by John, enters the set during the Mystery Guest segment and then is kicked out, also hilariously on-camera) [GSN/CC-1]
- (1-27-63) Mystery Guest: Maurice Chevalier [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-9-63) Mystery Guest: Bill Cullen [CC-1/C+]
- (2-9-64) Mystery Guest: Johnny Mercer and Jane Fonda [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-3-64) Mystery Guest: The McGuire Sisters [GSN/CC-1]
- (9-14-64) Mystery Guest: Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-4-64) Mystery Guest: Steve Allen (or is it... Forest Ranger?) (John accidentally reveals who the Mystery Guest is!!) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-11-64) Mystery Guest: The Boyer Brothers, two World Series third basemen, and Phyllis Diller (Bennett references the "Forest Ranger" flub from last week) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-18-64) Mystery Guest: Brian Epstein and Tony Bennett [GSN/CC-1, also available in A+ quality from a 2023 GSN airing on CC-2]
- (1-24-65) Mystery Guest: Jack Lemmon [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-21-65) Mystery Guest: James Mason [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-28-65) Mystery Guest: Tommy Sands and Nancy Sinatra [GSN/CC-1]
- (3-21-65) Mystery Guest: Art Carney (Arlene accidentally calls Alan King "Alan Dale") [GSN/CC-1]
- (4-4-65) Mystery Guest: Maurice Chevalier (Johnny Olson also appears to stump the panel as a Mystery Guest) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (4-11-65) Mystery Guest: George Jessel [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-2-65) Mystery Guest: Jack Jones [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-9-65) Mystery Guest: Soupy Sales [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-16-65) Mystery Guest: Liza Minnelli (Missing intro) [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-23-65) Mystery Guest: Robert Goulet [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-30-65) Mystery Guest: Tony Newley and Joan Collins [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-6-65) Mystery Guest: Tallulah Bankhead [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-13-65) Mystery Guest: Art Linkletter [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-20-65) Mystery Guest: George Hamilton [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-27-65) Mystery Guest: Ethel Merman [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-4-65) Mystery Guest: Trini Lopez [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-18-65) Mystery Guest: Milton Berle [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-25-65) Mystery Guest: Carol Channing, Ginger Rogers, and Lucille Ball [GSN/CC-1]
- (8-8-65) Mystery Guest: Olivia DeHavilland [GSN/CC-1]
- (8-29-65) Mystery Guest: Betty Grable [GSN/CC-1]
- (9-5-65) Mystery Guest: Allen Ludden and Betty White [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-3-65) Mystery Guest: Sean Connery and Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-17-65) Mystery Guest: Oscar Levant [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-24-65) Mystery Guest: Bette Davis and Danny Kaye [GSN/CC-1]
- (11-7-65) Mystery Guest: Joey Heatherton (Dorothy Kilgallen's final show before her death) [GSN/CC-1]
- (11-14-65) Mystery Guest: Maureen O'Sullivan (The first post-Dorothy Kilgallen show) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1-9-66) Mystery Guest: Polly Bergen and Hugh Hefner [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-13-66) Mystery Guest: Harry Belafonte (Mark Goodson appears on the panel. It's the show's 16th anniversary) [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-4-66) Mystery Guest: Angela Lansbury [GSN/CC-2]
- (1-22-67) Mystery Guest: Vince Lombardi, and Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass [GSN/CC-1]
- (3-5-67) Mystery Guest: Jacqueline Susann and Judy Garland [GSN/CC-1, also available from BUZZRw/OC in A+ quality]
- (6-11-67) Mystery Guest: Melina Mercouri (John Harlan sub-announces) [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-16-67) Mystery Guest: Bud Collyer, Allen Ludden, Gene Rayburn, and Ed McMahon!! [KINw/OC/CC-1/B+]
- (8-13-67) Mystery Guest: Woody Allen [GSN/CC-1]
- (9-3-67) Mystery Guest: John Charles Daly (Finale, and a lovely close out to the show) [KINw/OC or GSN/CC-1/B+ for both]
Wally Bruner (99 episodes)
- (9-6-68) Mystery Guest: Joel Grey (Premiere, with early wrinkles and all, including different camera zooms and silence during the sign-ins. Weak video, squiggly and off-colored) [GSN/CC-1/B-, also available in A+ quality from BUZZR on CC-2 but with weird editing thanks to BUZZR so starts at Johnny introducing the panel rather than the intro for some reason. I don't get it either]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Joan Rivers (From the premiere week of the series) [GSN/CC-1/A+, also available from BUZZR on CC-2 in the same quality but with the panel introductions edited by BUZZR]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Gordon MacRae [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Allan Sherman [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Mel Tormé [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Bennett Cerf [GSN/CC-1/B+, also available from BUZZR in A+ quality but with the panel introductions edited out for their usual stupid reasons]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Dr. Joyce Brothers (Another one where the panel introductions are edited out by BUZZR) [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Godfrey Cambridge (Panel introductions edited out by BUZZR) [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Sam Levenson [SM/CC-1/B-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Dustin Hoffman [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara, and Bozo the Clown (Very low audio, and video is quite jumpy) [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Morey Amsterdam (Low audio and jumpy video) [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Julie London [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Gene Rayburn (Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Jack Cassidy [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Willie Mays [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Gerald Ford [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Joe Garagiola [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Denny McLain [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Frankie Avalon [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Barbara Walters [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Shirley Jones (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: James Earl Jones, with movie stuntman Janos Prohaska signing in as Mr. X X in another game [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Jack E. Leonard (Audio/video get out of sync later on) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) A partial episode (Taped 8-20-68. Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Rodney Dangerfield [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Art Linkletter [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Charles Atlas and Jackie "Moms" Mabley [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bud Collyer (Video is very bright) [GSN/CC-1/C-]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Marcel Marceau [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Fannie Flagg [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bob Crane (Everyone plays volleyball) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Jackie Robinson [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Kaye Ballard [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bert Parks [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Dina Merrill (Low audio) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: George Carlin [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: James Brown [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Vidal Sassoon [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Ozzie Nelson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Hugh Downs [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Ann Miller [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Jaye P. Morgan (Taped 9-18-69) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Tiny Tim (Taped 10-2-69. Monti Rock appears as a guest in the first game. Tiny Tim casually dropping baseball analysis knowledge for a brief moment kinda caught me off guard and ruled) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: John Davidson (Very poor aspect ratio and some cable glitching throughout) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Juliet Mills [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Claire Trevor (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bill Cullen [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Harriet Nelson [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: June Lockhart [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Wally Bruner (Wally acts as Mystery Guest and emcee. Video is a little muddy) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Melba Moore [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jerry Orbach [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Michael Caine [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Lily Tomlin (Missing goodbye segment) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Betty Hutton (Gene Wood sub-announces) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Phil Rizzuto (Gene Wood sub-announces) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Larry Blyden (The 500th episode of the syndicated series. Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jack Narz (Taped 4-9-70) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Burgess Meredith (Taped 4-23-70. Gene Rayburn enters on a bicycle!!) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A, also available in A+ quality from BUZZR on CC-1]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jim Bouton [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Kitty Carlisle [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Sal Mineo (Everyone, including Wally, inhales helium) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Ed McMahon (A contestant coordinator for the show appears as a contestant!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Paul Anka (Video is jumpy and the audio is a little fuzzy. Everyone, including Wally, lies down on a water bed. Wally Bruner lying on a water bed is a creepier sight than one would imagine) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Joseph Cotten and Patricia Medina (Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Peggy Cass [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Joe Garagiola [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Elaine Stritch (Miss Universe Gloria Diaz signs in as Miss X in game one. Cuts off in the middle of the ending segment) [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Tony Randall [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jake LaMotta [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Alan Alda [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Cass Elliot [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Larry Kert (Missing panel introductions because that's how BUZZR rolls for some reason) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Odetta (Eamonn Andrews, host of the UK version of the show, is on the panel. And in a first, that is a jazzy cover of "Let the Sunshine In" that they're using for Who's Who, yes. I'm confused too) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jack Carter in one game, Olympic track champion Wilma Rudolph in another (Taped 3-5-70. Jack Carter namedrops "Second Guessers", which at that point was going to be sold afterall (wonder what happened?). Jack is having a blast being a giant loud goof after his game is cut short) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+, also available as a studio master with the slate, ripped from YouTube in the same quality on CC-2]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Rich Little (Taped 3-19-70) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Clayton Moore, The Lone Ranger in one game, and Shelley Winters in another (Taped 4-16-70. Ripped from YouTube. Soupy has tons of fun talking about The Lone Ranger lore with Clayton Moore and it's very endearing) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: NFL players Gary Cuozzo and Billy Cannon in one game, and Frankie Avalon in another (Taped 5-14-70. Ripped from YouTube. Bert Convy out here looking like he just woke up ten minutes ago and forgot he was supposed to be at the show) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Mel Brooks (Taped 11-5-70. Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [SMw/slate/CC-1/B, also available in A+ quality from BUZZR but missing the panel introductions because you know how BUZZR rolls at this point]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Carl Stokes (Taped 12-3-70. Ripped from YouTube. The chalkboard actually FALLS OFF as a guest is trying to sign in!! Jay Fiondella, bit actor who also ran a very successful celebrity-visited Santa Monica restaurant, signs in with a secret third occupation he has) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+, also available from BUZZR also on CC-2 in the same quality]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Gene Hackman (Also available from an older GSN airing with un-"crunched" credits) [GSN/CC-1/A+ or A-]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Burt Reynolds (One of Bennett Cerf's last appearances on the panel) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: James Earl Jones [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Bobby Murcer [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Satchel Paige (Legendary fashion designer Halston signs-in as Mr. X in game one) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Florence Henderson (Taped 3-4-71) [GSN/CC-2/A-]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Monty Hall (Tapped 11-24-71) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Hugh Downs (The first contestant in this game would also be a central subject on an episode of To Tell the Truth in the same year. Why do I know this? She's the subject when that hilarious blooper occurs where the subject introduction music gets sped up accidentally. Anyway, yes I am single I don't know why you're asking. Soupy going fucking IN on making fun of the Ku Klux Klan is one of those jokes that John Charles Daly would be internally screaming at on the original version of the show. You can tell why he acted like this one never existed) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Joe Frazier [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Robert Clary, in a great and funny round!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Jo Anne Worley [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Lou Gossett [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Betty White [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Fannie Flagg [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Little Richard [GSN/CC-2/A+]
- (9-23-71) Mystery Guest: Frank Zappa (Video is dark. Johnny Olson makes a funny cameo) [GSN/CC-1/B]
Larry Blyden (97 episodes)
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Peter Lind Hayes (Missing panel introductions because we know how BUZZR rolls by now. Larry's first taped episode) [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Jack E. Leonard [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Joan Fontaine [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Agnes Moorehead [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Jerry Orbach [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Ruby Keeler (Missing ending segment) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Jo Anne Worley [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Julie Harris [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Garry Moore (Some tracking issues in the beginning, but fine after that) [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1972) A partial episode featuring the first ten minutes or so (Ripped from YouTube. Counts as half of an episode due to its length) [OB/CC-1/B]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Dizzy Gillespie [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Professor Irwin Corey [CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Bill Todman (Video is a little blurry. Mark Goodson is on the panel) [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Bob and Ray [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Rodney Dangerfield [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Joey Adams [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Lainie Kazan (A contestant is Edward Parker, President of Parker Brothers!!) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Peter Nero [RPTw/OC/CC-1/C+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Joan Fontaine. Also Jimmy Carter in another game. [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Big Bird [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Art Fleming (Taped 2-1-73) [GSN/CC-1/B, also have the Art Fleming segment available from a studio master with the slate on CC-2!!]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Patsy Kelly [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Eddie Egan [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Agnes Moorehead (Glitchy video) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jerry Orbach [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Ossie Davis [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Wally Bruner (Wally's return to the show) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Paul Lynde (Video is slightly shaky) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Binnie Barnes (Missing goodbye segment) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Gordie Howe (Low audio) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Stevie Wonder [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Geoffrey Holder [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Mark Goodson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Adrienne Barbeau (Soupy is the last one introduced onto the panel, in a certainly bizarre seating placement) [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Sandy Dennis [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Kevin McCarthy [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Connie Francis (The man who created "Egg-Beaters" is a contestant) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Loretta Swit [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Lucie Arnaz (Arlene has the most interesting time trying a fortune cookie) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Bernadette Peters (The inventor of the LP record signs in as Mr. X in an earlier game!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Ozzie and Harriet Nelson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Vida Blue [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Shelley Berman (Panelist Marcia Rodd falls out of her chair at one point!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jacqueline Bisset [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Cab Calloway [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Dick Clark [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Walt Frazier [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Hal Linden [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Allen Funt (some audio and tracking issues for a few minutes [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jack Carter [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Nipsey Russell (Missing ending goodbye segment) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Alan Sues [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Ted Knight (Audio is a little low. Larry Blyden rules) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Leonard Nimoy [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jack Palance (Jack's game is pretty early, and they even do a Who's Who immediately afterwards, which makes me think one of the contestants had to last minute cancel) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Carl Reiner (the game with Carl ends earlier than expected so Larry has them play a bit from a comedy record Reiner did with Mel Brooks which is one of my favorite things they've done in this series) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: McLean Stevenson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Richard Chamberlain (Taped 2-8-73) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Anita Gillette (Gene announces that Match Game '73 is the number one show in daytime as of this taping!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Darren McGavin [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Robert Shaw (I adore the syndicated version of this show but after awhile it gets absolutely brutally monotonous seeing the same ten people rotate in and out as panelists over and over again. What I'm saying is Greg Morris is on the panel for this one and thank god because with how much WML? I've been watching lately I've been getting serious fatigue. Greg adds some much needed personality to the show) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Nancy Walker [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Frankie Laine (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Eileen Heckart (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Gordon MacRae (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Peter Gabel, in a great round where he stumps the entire panel, shocking Arlene the most of course!! [GSN/CC-2/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Pat Carroll in one game and Johnny Olson in another!! (Very early episode with the new set, not yet featuring the new opening!!) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Myrna Loy [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Enzo Stuarti [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Captain Kangaroo [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Bobby Van and Elaine Joyce [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Barbara McNair [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Phyllis Newman [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Peggy Cass [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Jackie Mason [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Peter Marshall [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Arlene Dahl [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Gene Shalit [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Rodney Dangerfield [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Morey Amsterdam [GSN/CC-/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Dick Cavett and Jim Henson [SM/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Don Murray [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Richard Dawson (Gene Rayburn is on the panel and he IMMEDIATELY realizes it's Richard so he disqualifies himself so the rest of the panel can try figuring out it's him) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Charles Nelson Reilly (Allen and Soupy are disqualified from playing the Mystery Guest round because they met Charles earlier in the week and they figured out he was gonna show up as the Mystery Guest!!) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Richard Deacon [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) A partial episode (Taped 10-25-74. Ripped from YouTube) [SM/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Art Carney [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Dave Garroway [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Jo Ann Pflug [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Estelle Parsons [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Rodney Allen Rippy, in a great round!! [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Tony Perkins [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Rex Reed [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Dick Shawn (The head of the Soupy Sales Fan Club shows up as a contestant!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Barbara Feldon [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Chita Rivera (Missing panel introductions because that's how BUZZR rolls for some reason) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Linda Blair [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1975) Mystery Guest: Ruby Dee (I wonder how "What's My Lime?" ice cream tastes?) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1975) Mystery Guest: Teddy Wilson (Low audio) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1975) Mystery Guest: Stuntman Frank Tallman, and What's My Line? announcer Chet Gould [GSN/CC-1/A-]
John Charles Daly (86 episodes)
- (10-1-50) Mystery Guest: Kathleen Winsor (Long lost episode discovered in 2016. Missing the last few minutes) [KINwOC/CC-2/A]
- (12-31-50) Mystery Guest: Guy Lombardo [GSN/CC-2/B+]
- (4-29-51) Mystery Guest: Hedda Hopper (Long lost episode discovered in 2016. Ripped from YouTube with on-screen watermark at various points. FANTASTIC questioning with a mattress manufacturer who is a great sport that absolutely would've made blooper specials if this episode had existed before its rediscovery!!) [KINw/OC/CC-2/A]
- (10-5-52) Mystery Guest: Bette Davis [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (3-8-53) Mystery Guest: Jackie Gleason [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (5-17-53) Mystery Guest: Mickey Mantle [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-4-53) Mystery Guest: Gene Autry in one game, World Series umpire Ed Hurley in another!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (11-8-53) Mystery Guest: Lauren Bacall [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (12-13-53) Mystery Guest: Dave Garroway [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-14-54) Mystery Guest: Julius LaRosa [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-21-54) Mystery Guest: Lucille Ball [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (9-12-54) Mystery Guest: Alfred Hitchcock, as well as Miss America Lee Meriwether in another game!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (6-19-55) Mystery Guest: Arnold Stang [GSN/CC-1/A+, also available with OC from BUZZR on CC-2 in the same quality]
- (7-24-55) Mystery Guest: Robert Q. Lewis [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-2-55) Mystery Guest: Desi Arnaz and Lucille Ball [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (10-9-55) Mystery Guest: Hal March [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-4-55) Mystery Guest: Vivian Blaine [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-25-55) Mystery Guest: Peter Lind Hayes and Mary Healy (Sylvette de Aldrey, a panelist on the Puerto Rican version of the show, is a contestant, and afterwards she joins the panel to play the Mystery Guest game as well as the last civilian contestant game!! Johnny Marks, writer of the song "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer, is a contestant) [BUZZRw/OC/CC-2/A+]
- (2-5-56) Mystery Guests: Randolph Churchill in one game, Kim Novak in another [KINw/OC/CC-1]
- (7-22-56) Mystery Guest: Jerry Lewis (Paul Winchell is on the panel, and the man who designed his dummy, Jerry Mahoney, signs in as Mr. X to surprise Paul!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-28-56) Mystery Guest: Charlton Heston [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (11-11-56) Mystery Guest: Walt Disney [GSN/CC-1/A+, also available in the same quality from BUZZRw/OC]
- (5-26-57) Mystery Guest: Sammy Davis, Jr. [BUZZRw/OC/CC-2/A+]
- (6-23-57) Mystery Guest: Gene Kelly [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (11-3-57) Mystery Guest: Jack Lemmon [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (6-15-58) Mystery Guest: Bob Crosby [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (3-8-59) Mystery Guest: Fred MacMurray [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (6-21-59) Mystery Guest: Jack Benny (As always Jack Benny steals the show with a great round) [GSN/CC-2]
- (9-20-59) Mystery Guest: Claudette Colbert (The is the *legendary* episode with Groucho Marx on the panel as he absolutely destroys the show by shutting down and making a mockery of its entire structure and leaving everyone in stitches the entire time. One of the greatest and funniest bits of 50s TV you will ever see in your entire life. It feels like they purposely picked these specific contestants because they knew they'd be tremendous getting grilled by Groucho, including a man who looks so strikingly like Nikita Khrushchev (even JOHN cracks jokes about it) that Groucho's "are you a corrupt politician?" question knocks the entire house down, and legendary women's professional wrestler Judy Grable, whose round is a HILARIOUS disaster where Groucho's remarks even make Dorothy crack, and then John finally gets fed up after having his worst laughing fit of his life!!) [GSN/CC-2]
- (2-7-60) Mystery Guest: Julie Andrews (It's the show's 10th anniversary as well as the 500th episode!!) [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (7-17-60) Mystery Guest: Jerry Lewis [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (8-21-60) Mystery Guest: Buddy Hackett [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-16-60) Mystery Guest: Danny Kaye (The show is only 25 minutes tonight due to another special airing later in the night, so the show moves at a slightly quicker rate!!) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-23-60) Mystery Guest: Janet Leigh (New York Yankees manager Ralph Houk is a Mystery Guest in the first game as well!!) [BUZZRw/OC/CC-1/A+]
- (12-11-60) Mystery Guest: Stephen Boyd [GSN/CC-1]
- (1-1-61) Mystery Guest: Lucille Ball [GSN/CC-1]
- (1-15-61) Mystery Guest: Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1-22-61) Mystery Guest: Mahalia Jackson [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1-29-61) Mystery Guest: Fashion designer Oleg Cassini in one game, Julie Newmar in another [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (7-2-61) Mystery Guest: Yogi Berra [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-3-61) Mystery Guest: Janet Leigh [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-4-62) Mystery Guest: Mark Goodson and Bill Todman in one game, and Bob Newhart in another (Mark and Bill are here to congratulate the panel on the 12th anniversary of the show) [GSN/CC-2]
- (10-7-62) Mystery Guest: Melina Mercouri (A man, hilariously called a "bad-mannered visitor" by John, enters the set during the Mystery Guest segment and then is kicked out, also hilariously on-camera) [GSN/CC-1]
- (1-27-63) Mystery Guest: Maurice Chevalier [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-9-63) Mystery Guest: Bill Cullen [CC-1/C+]
- (2-9-64) Mystery Guest: Johnny Mercer and Jane Fonda [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-3-64) Mystery Guest: The McGuire Sisters [GSN/CC-1]
- (9-14-64) Mystery Guest: Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-4-64) Mystery Guest: Steve Allen (or is it... Forest Ranger?) (John accidentally reveals who the Mystery Guest is!!) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-11-64) Mystery Guest: The Boyer Brothers, two World Series third basemen, and Phyllis Diller (Bennett references the "Forest Ranger" flub from last week) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (10-18-64) Mystery Guest: Brian Epstein and Tony Bennett [GSN/CC-1, also available in A+ quality from a 2023 GSN airing on CC-2]
- (1-24-65) Mystery Guest: Jack Lemmon [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-21-65) Mystery Guest: James Mason [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-28-65) Mystery Guest: Tommy Sands and Nancy Sinatra [GSN/CC-1]
- (3-21-65) Mystery Guest: Art Carney (Arlene accidentally calls Alan King "Alan Dale") [GSN/CC-1]
- (4-4-65) Mystery Guest: Maurice Chevalier (Johnny Olson also appears to stump the panel as a Mystery Guest) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (4-11-65) Mystery Guest: George Jessel [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-2-65) Mystery Guest: Jack Jones [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-9-65) Mystery Guest: Soupy Sales [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-16-65) Mystery Guest: Liza Minnelli (Missing intro) [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-23-65) Mystery Guest: Robert Goulet [GSN/CC-1]
- (5-30-65) Mystery Guest: Tony Newley and Joan Collins [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-6-65) Mystery Guest: Tallulah Bankhead [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-13-65) Mystery Guest: Art Linkletter [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-20-65) Mystery Guest: George Hamilton [GSN/CC-1]
- (6-27-65) Mystery Guest: Ethel Merman [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-4-65) Mystery Guest: Trini Lopez [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-18-65) Mystery Guest: Milton Berle [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-25-65) Mystery Guest: Carol Channing, Ginger Rogers, and Lucille Ball [GSN/CC-1]
- (8-8-65) Mystery Guest: Olivia DeHavilland [GSN/CC-1]
- (8-29-65) Mystery Guest: Betty Grable [GSN/CC-1]
- (9-5-65) Mystery Guest: Allen Ludden and Betty White [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-3-65) Mystery Guest: Sean Connery and Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-17-65) Mystery Guest: Oscar Levant [GSN/CC-1]
- (10-24-65) Mystery Guest: Bette Davis and Danny Kaye [GSN/CC-1]
- (11-7-65) Mystery Guest: Joey Heatherton (Dorothy Kilgallen's final show before her death) [GSN/CC-1]
- (11-14-65) Mystery Guest: Maureen O'Sullivan (The first post-Dorothy Kilgallen show) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1-9-66) Mystery Guest: Polly Bergen and Hugh Hefner [GSN/CC-1]
- (2-13-66) Mystery Guest: Harry Belafonte (Mark Goodson appears on the panel. It's the show's 16th anniversary) [GSN/CC-1]
- (12-4-66) Mystery Guest: Angela Lansbury [GSN/CC-2]
- (1-22-67) Mystery Guest: Vince Lombardi, and Herb Alpert and the Tijuana Brass [GSN/CC-1]
- (3-5-67) Mystery Guest: Jacqueline Susann and Judy Garland [GSN/CC-1, also available from BUZZRw/OC in A+ quality]
- (6-11-67) Mystery Guest: Melina Mercouri (John Harlan sub-announces) [GSN/CC-1]
- (7-16-67) Mystery Guest: Bud Collyer, Allen Ludden, Gene Rayburn, and Ed McMahon!! [KINw/OC/CC-1/B+]
- (8-13-67) Mystery Guest: Woody Allen [GSN/CC-1]
- (9-3-67) Mystery Guest: John Charles Daly (Finale, and a lovely close out to the show) [KINw/OC or GSN/CC-1/B+ for both]
Wally Bruner (99 episodes)
- (9-6-68) Mystery Guest: Joel Grey (Premiere, with early wrinkles and all, including different camera zooms and silence during the sign-ins. Weak video, squiggly and off-colored) [GSN/CC-1/B-, also available in A+ quality from BUZZR on CC-2 but with weird editing thanks to BUZZR so starts at Johnny introducing the panel rather than the intro for some reason. I don't get it either]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Joan Rivers (From the premiere week of the series) [GSN/CC-1/A+, also available from BUZZR on CC-2 in the same quality but with the panel introductions edited by BUZZR]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Gordon MacRae [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Allan Sherman [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Mel Tormé [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Bennett Cerf [GSN/CC-1/B+, also available from BUZZR in A+ quality but with the panel introductions edited out for their usual stupid reasons]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Dr. Joyce Brothers (Another one where the panel introductions are edited out by BUZZR) [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Godfrey Cambridge (Panel introductions edited out by BUZZR) [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Sam Levenson [SM/CC-1/B-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Dustin Hoffman [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Jerry Stiller and Anne Meara, and Bozo the Clown (Very low audio, and video is quite jumpy) [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Morey Amsterdam (Low audio and jumpy video) [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Julie London [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Gene Rayburn (Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Jack Cassidy [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Willie Mays [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Gerald Ford [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Joe Garagiola [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Denny McLain [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Frankie Avalon [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Barbara Walters [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Shirley Jones (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: James Earl Jones, with movie stuntman Janos Prohaska signing in as Mr. X X in another game [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) Mystery Guest: Jack E. Leonard (Audio/video get out of sync later on) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1968) A partial episode (Taped 8-20-68. Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Rodney Dangerfield [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Art Linkletter [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Charles Atlas and Jackie "Moms" Mabley [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bud Collyer (Video is very bright) [GSN/CC-1/C-]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Marcel Marceau [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Fannie Flagg [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bob Crane (Everyone plays volleyball) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Jackie Robinson [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Kaye Ballard [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bert Parks [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Dina Merrill (Low audio) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: George Carlin [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: James Brown [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Henry Fonda [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Vidal Sassoon [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Ozzie Nelson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Hugh Downs [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Ann Miller [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Jaye P. Morgan (Taped 9-18-69) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Tiny Tim (Taped 10-2-69. Monti Rock appears as a guest in the first game. Tiny Tim casually dropping baseball analysis knowledge for a brief moment kinda caught me off guard and ruled) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: John Davidson (Very poor aspect ratio and some cable glitching throughout) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Juliet Mills [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Claire Trevor (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Bill Cullen [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: Harriet Nelson [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1969) Mystery Guest: June Lockhart [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Wally Bruner (Wally acts as Mystery Guest and emcee. Video is a little muddy) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Melba Moore [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jerry Orbach [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Michael Caine [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Lily Tomlin (Missing goodbye segment) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Betty Hutton (Gene Wood sub-announces) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Phil Rizzuto (Gene Wood sub-announces) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Larry Blyden (The 500th episode of the syndicated series. Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jack Narz (Taped 4-9-70) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Burgess Meredith (Taped 4-23-70. Gene Rayburn enters on a bicycle!!) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A, also available in A+ quality from BUZZR on CC-1]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jim Bouton [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Kitty Carlisle [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Sal Mineo (Everyone, including Wally, inhales helium) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Ed McMahon (A contestant coordinator for the show appears as a contestant!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Paul Anka (Video is jumpy and the audio is a little fuzzy. Everyone, including Wally, lies down on a water bed. Wally Bruner lying on a water bed is a creepier sight than one would imagine) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Joseph Cotten and Patricia Medina (Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Peggy Cass [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Joe Garagiola [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Elaine Stritch (Miss Universe Gloria Diaz signs in as Miss X in game one. Cuts off in the middle of the ending segment) [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Tony Randall [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jake LaMotta [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Alan Alda [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Cass Elliot [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Larry Kert (Missing panel introductions because that's how BUZZR rolls for some reason) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Odetta (Eamonn Andrews, host of the UK version of the show, is on the panel. And in a first, that is a jazzy cover of "Let the Sunshine In" that they're using for Who's Who, yes. I'm confused too) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Jack Carter in one game, Olympic track champion Wilma Rudolph in another (Taped 3-5-70. Jack Carter namedrops "Second Guessers", which at that point was going to be sold afterall (wonder what happened?). Jack is having a blast being a giant loud goof after his game is cut short) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+, also available as a studio master with the slate, ripped from YouTube in the same quality on CC-2]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Rich Little (Taped 3-19-70) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Clayton Moore, The Lone Ranger in one game, and Shelley Winters in another (Taped 4-16-70. Ripped from YouTube. Soupy has tons of fun talking about The Lone Ranger lore with Clayton Moore and it's very endearing) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: NFL players Gary Cuozzo and Billy Cannon in one game, and Frankie Avalon in another (Taped 5-14-70. Ripped from YouTube. Bert Convy out here looking like he just woke up ten minutes ago and forgot he was supposed to be at the show) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Mel Brooks (Taped 11-5-70. Johnny Olson makes a cameo) [SMw/slate/CC-1/B, also available in A+ quality from BUZZR but missing the panel introductions because you know how BUZZR rolls at this point]
- (1970) Mystery Guest: Carl Stokes (Taped 12-3-70. Ripped from YouTube. The chalkboard actually FALLS OFF as a guest is trying to sign in!! Jay Fiondella, bit actor who also ran a very successful celebrity-visited Santa Monica restaurant, signs in with a secret third occupation he has) [SMw/slate/CC-2/A+, also available from BUZZR also on CC-2 in the same quality]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Gene Hackman (Also available from an older GSN airing with un-"crunched" credits) [GSN/CC-1/A+ or A-]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Burt Reynolds (One of Bennett Cerf's last appearances on the panel) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: James Earl Jones [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Bobby Murcer [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Satchel Paige (Legendary fashion designer Halston signs-in as Mr. X in game one) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Florence Henderson (Taped 3-4-71) [GSN/CC-2/A-]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Monty Hall (Tapped 11-24-71) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Hugh Downs (The first contestant in this game would also be a central subject on an episode of To Tell the Truth in the same year. Why do I know this? She's the subject when that hilarious blooper occurs where the subject introduction music gets sped up accidentally. Anyway, yes I am single I don't know why you're asking. Soupy going fucking IN on making fun of the Ku Klux Klan is one of those jokes that John Charles Daly would be internally screaming at on the original version of the show. You can tell why he acted like this one never existed) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Joe Frazier [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Robert Clary, in a great and funny round!! [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Jo Anne Worley [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Lou Gossett [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Betty White [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Fannie Flagg [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1971) Mystery Guest: Little Richard [GSN/CC-2/A+]
- (9-23-71) Mystery Guest: Frank Zappa (Video is dark. Johnny Olson makes a funny cameo) [GSN/CC-1/B]
Larry Blyden (97 episodes)
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Peter Lind Hayes (Missing panel introductions because we know how BUZZR rolls by now. Larry's first taped episode) [BUZZR/CC-2/A+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Jack E. Leonard [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Joan Fontaine [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Agnes Moorehead [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Jerry Orbach [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Ruby Keeler (Missing ending segment) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Jo Anne Worley [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Julie Harris [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Garry Moore (Some tracking issues in the beginning, but fine after that) [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1972) A partial episode featuring the first ten minutes or so (Ripped from YouTube. Counts as half of an episode due to its length) [OB/CC-1/B]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Dizzy Gillespie [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1972) Mystery Guest: Professor Irwin Corey [CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Bill Todman (Video is a little blurry. Mark Goodson is on the panel) [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Bob and Ray [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Rodney Dangerfield [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Joey Adams [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Lainie Kazan (A contestant is Edward Parker, President of Parker Brothers!!) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Peter Nero [RPTw/OC/CC-1/C+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Joan Fontaine. Also Jimmy Carter in another game. [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Big Bird [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Art Fleming (Taped 2-1-73) [GSN/CC-1/B, also have the Art Fleming segment available from a studio master with the slate on CC-2!!]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Patsy Kelly [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Eddie Egan [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Agnes Moorehead (Glitchy video) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jerry Orbach [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Ossie Davis [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Wally Bruner (Wally's return to the show) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Paul Lynde (Video is slightly shaky) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Binnie Barnes (Missing goodbye segment) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Gordie Howe (Low audio) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Stevie Wonder [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Geoffrey Holder [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Mark Goodson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Adrienne Barbeau (Soupy is the last one introduced onto the panel, in a certainly bizarre seating placement) [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Sandy Dennis [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Kevin McCarthy [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Connie Francis (The man who created "Egg-Beaters" is a contestant) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Loretta Swit [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Lucie Arnaz (Arlene has the most interesting time trying a fortune cookie) [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Bernadette Peters (The inventor of the LP record signs in as Mr. X in an earlier game!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Ozzie and Harriet Nelson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Vida Blue [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Shelley Berman (Panelist Marcia Rodd falls out of her chair at one point!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jacqueline Bisset [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Cab Calloway [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Dick Clark [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Walt Frazier [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Hal Linden [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Allen Funt (some audio and tracking issues for a few minutes [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jack Carter [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Nipsey Russell (Missing ending goodbye segment) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Alan Sues [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Ted Knight (Audio is a little low. Larry Blyden rules) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Leonard Nimoy [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Jack Palance (Jack's game is pretty early, and they even do a Who's Who immediately afterwards, which makes me think one of the contestants had to last minute cancel) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Carl Reiner (the game with Carl ends earlier than expected so Larry has them play a bit from a comedy record Reiner did with Mel Brooks which is one of my favorite things they've done in this series) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: McLean Stevenson [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Richard Chamberlain (Taped 2-8-73) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Anita Gillette (Gene announces that Match Game '73 is the number one show in daytime as of this taping!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Darren McGavin [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Robert Shaw (I adore the syndicated version of this show but after awhile it gets absolutely brutally monotonous seeing the same ten people rotate in and out as panelists over and over again. What I'm saying is Greg Morris is on the panel for this one and thank god because with how much WML? I've been watching lately I've been getting serious fatigue. Greg adds some much needed personality to the show) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Nancy Walker [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Frankie Laine (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Eileen Heckart (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Gordon MacRae (Ripped from YouTube) [SMw/slate/CC-1/A+]
- (1973) Mystery Guest: Peter Gabel, in a great round where he stumps the entire panel, shocking Arlene the most of course!! [GSN/CC-2/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Pat Carroll in one game and Johnny Olson in another!! (Very early episode with the new set, not yet featuring the new opening!!) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Myrna Loy [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Enzo Stuarti [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Captain Kangaroo [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Bobby Van and Elaine Joyce [GSN/CC-1/A-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Barbara McNair [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Phyllis Newman [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Peggy Cass [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Jackie Mason [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Peter Marshall [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Arlene Dahl [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Gene Shalit [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Rodney Dangerfield [GSN/CC-1/B-]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Morey Amsterdam [GSN/CC-/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Dick Cavett and Jim Henson [SM/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Don Murray [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Richard Dawson (Gene Rayburn is on the panel and he IMMEDIATELY realizes it's Richard so he disqualifies himself so the rest of the panel can try figuring out it's him) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Charles Nelson Reilly (Allen and Soupy are disqualified from playing the Mystery Guest round because they met Charles earlier in the week and they figured out he was gonna show up as the Mystery Guest!!) [GSN/CC-1/B+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Richard Deacon [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) A partial episode (Taped 10-25-74. Ripped from YouTube) [SM/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Art Carney [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Dave Garroway [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Jo Ann Pflug [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Estelle Parsons [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Rodney Allen Rippy, in a great round!! [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Tony Perkins [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Rex Reed [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Dick Shawn (The head of the Soupy Sales Fan Club shows up as a contestant!!) [GSN/CC-1/A]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Barbara Feldon [GSN/CC-1/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Chita Rivera (Missing panel introductions because that's how BUZZR rolls for some reason) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1974) Mystery Guest: Linda Blair [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1975) Mystery Guest: Ruby Dee (I wonder how "What's My Lime?" ice cream tastes?) [BUZZR/CC-1/A+]
- (1975) Mystery Guest: Teddy Wilson (Low audio) [GSN/CC-1/B]
- (1975) Mystery Guest: Stuntman Frank Tallman, and What's My Line? announcer Chet Gould [GSN/CC-1/A-]